2008 General Election Judicial Candidate Ratings

Click on a candidate's name for biographical information.

Printer Friendly Ratings

Contested Races
  Candidate Average
Rating
Cleveland
Metropolitan Bar
Association
Cuyahoga Criminal Defense Lawyers Association Norman S.
Minor Bar
Association
Ohio
Women's
Bar
Association
The
Call &
Post*
The
Plain
Dealer*
Supreme Court of Ohio Starting 1/1/09 Maureen
O'Connor
1.75 Adequate Adequate Not Recommended Good Endorsed Endorsed
Joseph D.
Russo
3.5 Good Excellent Excellent Good    
Supreme Court of Ohio
Starting
1/2/09
Peter M.
Sikora
3.25 Good Good Good Excellent   Endorsed
Evelyn
Stratton
3.75 Excellent Excellent Good –
Preferred
Excellent–
Preferred
Endorsed  
8th District
Court of Appeals Starting
2/10/09
Larry
Jones
3.5 Good Excellent Excellent Good -
Preferred
Endorsed Endorsed
R. Brian
Moriarty
2.5 Adequate Good Adequate Good    

 

Candidate Average
Rating
Cleveland
Metropolitan Bar
Association
Cuyahoga Criminal Defense Lawyers Association Norman S.
Minor Bar
Association
Ohio
Women's
Bar
Association
The
Call &
Post*
The
Plain
Dealer*
Common Pleas
General
Division
Starting
1/3/09
Robert C. McClelland 2.25 Good Good Not Recommended Good -
Preferred
   
Steven
Terry
3.25 Good Good Excellent Good Endorsed Endorsed
Common Pleas
General
Division
Starting
1/10/09
Richard J. McMonagle 4.0 Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent Endorsed Endorsed
Lynn McLaughlin Murray 2.0 Adequate Adequate Adequate Adequate    
Common Pleas
General
Division
Starting
2/9/09
Deena
Calabrese
3.0 Good Good Good Good Endorsed Endorsed
Sam
Zingale
1.0 Not
Recommended
Adequate Not Recommended Adequate    
Common Pleas
General Division Unexpired Term Ending 1/4/11
Lance
T. Mason
3.25 Good-
Preferred
Good Excellent Good Endorsed Endorsed
Pamela A.
Barker
2.25 Good Adequate Adequate Adequate    
Common Pleas
Probate
Starting
2/9/09
Laura
Gallagher
2.5 Adequate Adequate Good Good -
Preferred
Endorsed  
Kathleen
Sutula
2.0 Adequate Good Not Recommended Good   Endorsed
 
Unopposed Candidates

 

Candidate Average
Rating
Cleveland
Metropolitan Bar
Association
Cuyahoga Criminal Defense Lawyers Association Norman S.
Minor Bar
Association
Ohio
Women's
Bar
Association
The
Call &
Post*
The
Plain
Dealer*
8th District
Court of Appeals Starting
2/9/09
Sean
Gallagher
4.0 Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent    
8th District
Court of Appeals Starting
2/11/09
Patricia
Blackmon
3.75 Good Excellent Excellent Excellent    
8th District
Court of Appeals Starting
2/12/09
Kenneth
Rocco
4.0 Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent    
Common Pleas
General
Division
Starting
1/1/09
Michael
Russo
3.75 Good Excellent Excellent Excellent    
Common Pleas
General Division
Starting
1/2/09
Nancy
Fuerst
4.0 Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent    
Common Pleas
General
Division
Starting
1/4/09
Nancy
McDonnell
3.5 Good Excellent Excellent Good    

 

Candidate Average
Rating
Cleveland
Metropolitan Bar
Association
Cuyahoga Criminal Defense Lawyers Association Norman S.
Minor Bar
Association
Ohio
Women's
Bar
Association
The
Call &
Post*
The
Plain
Dealer*
Common Pleas
General
Division
Starting
1/5/09
Brendan
Sheehan
3.0 Good Good Good Good    
Common Pleas
General
Division
Starting
1/6/09
Eileen A.
Gallagher
4.0 Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent    
Common Pleas
General
Division
Starting
1/7/09
Nancy Margaret Russo 3.0 Adequate Excellent Excellent Adequate    
Common Pleas
Domestic Relations
Starting
1/8/09
Timothy
Flanagan
0.0 Refused to Participate Refused to Participate Refused to Participate Refused to Participate    
Common Pleas Domestic Relations
Starting
1/9/09
Leslie Ann Celebrezze 0.0 Not
Recommended
Not Recommended Not Recommended Not Recommended    
Common Pleas Probate
Starting
1/1/09
Anthony
Russo
3.5 Good Good Excellent Excellent    

*The Plain Dealer and Call & Post are not part of the JCRC. We include their ratings as a public service.